What we make and how they can be ordered online…

  • All special orders must be placed through the following methods:
    • Filling out and submitting a Google Form under the “Special Orders” tab on this website
    • Calling in to the bakery (937.705.6605); our hours of operation are, M-F, 9am – 5pm; Sat, 10am – 4pm
    • Emailing your orders to
    • Walk-in ordering at the bakery itself (3375 Dayton-Xenia Road, Beavercreek, OH)
  • We ask for 5-7 business days advance notice on all special orders – your order will not be complete until a team member contacts you
  • Orders placed online will be limited with selections. Even though we offer all of the following items to be ordered ahead of time, we would appreciate reserving special ordering for cakes/cupcakes/pies/breads or other specialty items listed on this menu.
  • The following menu items are items that we frequently make, but each of our wholesale locations (coffee shops, grocery stores, etc.) may not have these items available every day of the week.
  • Prices may be subject to change due to the fluctuating costs of our ingredients – the final cost of each product will be communicated to you prior to purchase.

Our Products

GF = Gluten Free, V = Vegan, DF = Dairy Free, SF = Soy Free, CF = Corn Free

**Corn Allergy Disclaimer: The natural dyes and sprinkles we use in our cakes, cupcakes, or donuts contain small amount of corn starch

Cakes and Cupcakes

Specialty Dessert Cakes 

Preorder Policy: 5-7 days advance notice

Our Specialty Cakes Must Be Handled With Care!

Transportation (especially in warm seasons): Keep cakes cool as much as possible (air conditioned cars, ice packs for longer travel plans)

Before serving: Allow cakes to sit out in room temperature for at least 30 minutes before serving. Gluten free/vegan cakes will feel hard to cut when cold, but will soften as it warms up to room temperature.

Gluten Free Only / Gluten Free / Dairy Free / Egg Free

Round Cakes (starting prices)

Sizes – Price – Serves

5″ Round (double layer) – $25 – (4)

6” Round (double layer) – $35.00 – (8-10)

8” Round (double layer) – $45.00 – (11-16)

10” Round (double layer) – $65.00 – (17 – 23)

Custom design pricing varies with design (15.00-20.00/hour for design and decoration)

Rectangular Cakes (starting prices)

Sizes – Price – Serves

¼ Sheet (8”x12”) – $45.00 (single layer) – up to 24

½ Sheet (12”x18”) – $75.00 (single layer) – up to 48

Cookie Cake 

10″ Size – $20

Custom design pricing varies with complexity (see above for per hour pricing)


Gluten Free Only / Gluten Free / Vegan

**The all-natural sprinkles that we use on our cupcakes may contain cornstarch

Size Price Per Serving

Standard (Vanilla, Chocolate, Marble, Lemon, Strawberry, Buckeye) – $4.00*

Filled with organic preserves or ganache – $4.25

Standard Specialty (Carrot Cake, German Chocolate, S’mores, Toppings) – $4.25

* discounted to $3.75 per cupcake for orders of 4 dozen or more

Wedding Cakes 

Preorder Policy: 50% down payment, minimum 30-day advance notice

If you are interested in doing a wedding cake tasting, please call the bakery and we will set up a tasting with you and the owner

Gluten Free Only / Gluten Free / Dairy Free / Egg Free

Type Price Per Serving

Gluten Free or Vegan Buttercream 3.50

Filled with organic fruit or ganache 4.50

Gluten Free or Vegan Fondant 5.50

Gluten Free or Vegan Fondant Filled with organic preserves or ganache 6.5

Standard Cake Flavors (no extra charge):  Vanilla, Dutch Chocolate, Marble, Lemon, Strawberry, Buckeye

Specialty Cake Flavors (5.00-10.00 extra):  Carrot Cake, German Chocolate, White Almond Cream


GF “Best Ever” Peanut Butter Cookies (contains eggs)

Jumbo $3; Standard Size – 6 pk $10

GF/V Chocolate Chip Cookies

5pk $9.50

GF/V Double Dutch Chocolate Chip Cookies

5pk for $9.75

GF/V Shortbread Cookies

Buttercream frosted – $3.50 each

Royal iced/Custom decorated- $4.00 each

GF/V Oatmeal Cream Pie Cookies

Individual $4, 4pk $16

Cookie Bars

GF/V Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip Bar

$4.50 each

GF/V Six Layer Gooey Bars

$4.50 each

Pie Bars

GF/V Peach Pie Slab Bar (seasonal/summer)

GF/V Apple Pie Slab Bar

GF/V Blueberry Pie Slab Bar (seasonal/summer)

GF/V Cherry Crumb Slab Bar (Special Request)

$4 per slice


GF Flourless Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie

$4 each

GF/V Double Chocolate Chip Brownie

$4 each

GF Lemon Brownie

$4 each

Whoopie Pies

GF/V Double Chocolate Whoopie Pie

$4 each


Available as GF/V in the following flavors: Almond Toscani, Cinnamon, Almond Orange, Dutch Chocolate, or White Chocolate Chip/Cranberry, Pumpkin Spice (seasonal)

Sold only as a 6-pack, $15


Available as GF/V in a variety of flavors: orange cranberry, lemon blueberry, cinnamon, strawberry cream, and pumpkin (seasonal).

$3 each

Sweet Breads

Gluten-free Orange Cranberry Bread (seasonal)

Gluten-Free Lemon Pound Cake

Gluten Free Pumpkin Bread (seasonal)

Gluten-Free Cherry Chocolate Chip Bread

Gluten-Free Banana Bread

$10 each

Cinnamon Rolls

GF/V Cinnamon Rolls (standard size)

6pk – $16.00

GF/V Cinnamon Roll (jumbo size)

$4.75 each

Coffee Cakes

Apple Cinnamon Coffee Cake

Lemon Blueberry Coffee Cake

Cherry Coffee Cake

Pumpkin Spice Coffee Cake (seasonal)

Gingerbread Coffee Cake (seasonal)

Peach Coffee Cake

All flavors available as GF/V – $4.00 each 


(All pies are made gluten free, but dairy free or vegan options available upon request)

Assorted Fruit Pies (seasonal) – Strawberry Rhubarb, Blackberry, Blueberry – $24

Dutch Apple Pie – $22 each

Pecan Pie – $26 each

Pumpkin Pie (seasonal) – $20 each


GF/V Variety Flavors

$4.00 each

Buckeye, Tuxedo, Strawberry, Dutch Chocolate, Maple (seasonal), Blueberry (seasonal), Red Velvet (seasonal), Deep-Fried Yeast Donuts (seasonal), Apple Fritters (seasonal)

Belgian Waffles

Plain, Cinnamon, Blueberry, Strawberry

This is a frozen food item located in our small freezer 

Available as GF/V – 4pk for $10


Plain and “The Works”

Available as GF/V – 4pk. for $12 

English Muffins

Plain (In store) & Garlic Parmesan (special order only)

Available as GF/V – 4pk. $10

Artisan Bread

Available as one bread loaf or a 6-pack of dinner rolls

Available as GF/V – $10 each

GF Artisan Flour Blend

Our gluten-free flour is a blend of brown rice flour, sweet rice flour, potato starch, tapioca starch, psyllium husk powder

Available in 24 oz. bags ($8)

We Have Even Healthier Options Too!

Paleo Granola

Made with sliced almonds, pecans, walnuts, pumpkin seeds and sunflower seeds, honey, coconut oil and various spices

Available in 3 flavors – Regular (raisins & coconut flakes), Apple Spice (dried apples & dried cranberries), Dutch Chocolate Cardamom (dutch cocoa, cardamom, dried cranberries, GF/V semi-sweet chocolate chips & coconut flakes)

Available in 12 oz. bags ($12) or in bulk (6 lbs) $90

Runner’s Energy Bars / Peanut Butter Chia Bars

Runner’s Energy Bars – Two, 2.5oz. bars made with almond butter, flax meal, oats, honey and GF/V choc chips

$6.50 each

Peanut Butter & Chia Seed Power Bars

$6.50 each

Keto Baked Goods

Keto Cupcakes

Available in a variety of flavors such as chocolate, buckeye, lemon blueberry, banana cream, strawberry and seasonal flavors

Available as a variety 2-pack for $9

Keto Cookies

Keto Peanut Butter Cookies (Dairy-Free)

Available as a 4-pack – $8.50

Keto Chocolate Chip Cookies

Available as a 4-pack – $8.50

Keto Almond Cookies

Available as a 4 pack – $6.50

Keto 6” Cakes 

(chocolate, coconut cream, strawberry) $40- online /call in order only

Keto Cinnamon Rolls with Cream Cheese Icing

Available as a 4-pack ($7)

Keto Bagels (plain or The Works)

Available individually for $4 or a 6-pack for $24

Allergen Notice and Dietary Needs

Gluten Free / Dairy Free / Egg Free** / Soy Free / Nut Free**

We prepare products in a facility that processes nuts. The dyes we use contain small amount of corn starch. Please list all dietary needs on Cake Order Form or online form. 

For more information, please call 937-705-6605.

Payment Policy

Prepayments will be required within 48 hours of placing your order unless arrangements have been communicated with PSB staff member. We accept the following methods:  credit card via telephone at 937-705-6605, PayPal, or Venmo. All sales are final as we purchase supplies in advance. No changes to orders will be accepted less than 48 hours prior to pickup date. All prices subject to change without notice.

**Allergen notice denotes that our products may be made free of said ingredient but does not infer that all of our products are made as such. However, we bake out of a 100% dedicated gluten-free facility.